Digital Dictatorship

The reality of that phrase is only now beginning to be felt in the post pandemic era—and it is to be feared.

By Dilip Bobb

Has the pandemic locked us into a high-tech dystopia? Two high profile social activists, Vandana Shiva in India, and Canadian author Naomi Klein, have both been warning of an age they call Digital Dictatorship, when the giants of the tech world will dominate the economy, and all our lives. In a recent report for The Intercept, Klein looked at how the coronavirus pandemic is more high-tech than previous disasters — and how the digital future we’re being rushed into could transform our lives into a “living laboratory for a permanent — and highly profitable — no-touch future.” This, she says, will massively benefit private tech interests. The hi-tech dystopia she and Shiva envision, is one where our every move, our every word, our every relationship is trackable, traceable and data-mineable by unprecedented collaborations between government and tech giants.

A parallel theory is that when a society experiences a major ‘shock’ there is a widespread desire for a rapid and decisive response to correct the situation; this desire for bold and immediate action provides an opportunity to implement policies which go far beyond a legitimate response to disaster. The theory, which Klein calls “Shock Doctrine,” posits that the pressure to act also leaves the door open for unpopular and unrelated policies to be rushed into effect. These shocks allow for what analysts have also termed “creative destruction.” Driven by fear, confusion and panic among their citizens, any countries from the US to China and even India, are presiding over Digital Dictatorships, where the push from government is to leapfrog to a future where everything, from food to learning, to work and worship, is going online. Experts call this “bio-defence” which in effect, enhances surveillance and control, and at the same time, reduces the value and effect of participatory democracy and individual rights and freedom.  

In the US, the big debate is over the upcoming elections and the fear and conspiracy theories being aired regarding postal ballots, which many Americans will prefer to do in the midst of a surge in Covid-19 infections and deaths. In China, the Communist Party is pushing for an increasingly aggressive role in global affairs and confrontation with the other Superpower, led by their tech giants Tencent and Bytedance. In the UK, the Boris Johnson government is angering the EU by changing its original agreement on Brexit, which in normal times, would have been settled by a popular referendum, as was the case with the birth of Brexit when people could go out and vote. In Russia, according to a recent US intelligence briefing, the Putin-led Kremlin is playing a major role in interfering in the November US elections, using technology and cyber warfare to affect the vote. In India, we are also seeing a dramatic, convulsive shift to online everything and where Facebook officials dare to ignore a summons by a parliamentary committee. Post the pandemic, India has attracted over $40 billion in a funding spree from major tech giants, such as Google and Facebook. Google CEO Sundar Pichai has stated that the technology giant will invest $10 billion in India over the next five years with a focus on digitising the economy and building products and services in consultation with the Indian government. Another tech titan, Apple, has just launched its first online store in India and promised major investments in future.

In fact, the digital dystopia that many social activists foresee is one where Silicon Valley, meaning Facebook, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple, Oracle, and other technology companies, are, together with governments, forming what could be the most powerful cabal in history. Before the pandemic, individuals had myriad options and digital transactions were restricted to a few areas of interest—the point was that you could opt out any time you wanted. Post the pandemic, those options no longer exist. Our offices are now our homes, which mean they are no longer private spaces. Without Amazon, Netflix, Facebook, Twitter and Whatsapp, even Zomato and Uber, where would our lives be?  The digital word, dominated by a few, has invaded our lives like never before, and the titans of Silicon Valley are the new Gods. For the privileged, fearful of Covid-19 disrupting their comfortable lives, everything is now home delivered or live streamed. What this also means is that the pandemic has created such huge swathes of unemployment, and the vacuum is being filled by digital players.  With education, banking and even medical consultation going online, will we see a dramatic drop in demand for teachers, health workers, domestic servants and other service providers? Cash is no longer king, so even banks may make do with lesser employees.

That leaves the field open for digital giants to increase their already considerable clout over individual and governments, or collaborate with them. We live in a world where everything is moving at warp speed, spurred by the digital onslaught. There is no longer time to think, to evaluate, to discuss, or even oppose this onslaught. The pandemic has robbed us our ability to do that. It has, at the same time, allowed governments and leaders to accelerate and introduce policies and schemes which may not have been so easy to implement in a pre-pandemic world. It is no coincidence that many of these are intended to dilute liberties and freedom, even identities. Welcome to the Digital Dictatorship.
The post Digital Dictatorship appeared first on India Legal.